Values have gone sideways while the rest of the country ran. But rents are rising, vacancy is tightening, and Melbourne now trades below Brisbane. Here is the honest investor case for Australia’s most out-of-favour capital.
Let us start with the hard truth, because the case for Melbourne only works if you are honest about the numbers. Over the past year Melbourne dwelling values have gone backwards, easing around 0.9% to a median near $808,000, with the softness concentrated in the most recent quarter. While Perth, Brisbane and Adelaide compounded through the cycle, Melbourne sat it out. It has been the weakest of the major capitals, full stop.
Prices are only half the story, and in Melbourne the other half is moving the opposite way. Rents are up about 4.9% over the year, vacancy has tightened to 1.6% (down from 1.8% a year ago), and gross yields have lifted to around 3.9%, higher than Brisbane. When rents rise and vacancy falls while prices sit still, the income case strengthens and the entry price does not. That is an unusual, and for a patient investor a useful, combination.
The years of underperformance have done something striking: Melbourne, long the second-most-expensive capital, is now cheaper than Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth. A median dwelling that sat well above Brisbane a few years ago now trades roughly a quarter below it. For a global city with the country’s strongest population growth, that is a genuine dislocation between price and fundamentals.
Victoria records the strongest population growth in the nation, and Melbourne is on track to overtake Sydney as Australia’s largest city within the decade. Every year adds tens of thousands of households that need somewhere to live.
Rents rose about 4.9% over the year while vacancy tightened to 1.6%. Yields near 3.9% now beat Brisbane. The rental market is doing the opposite of the price market.
After years of flat prices, Melbourne is cheaper than Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth. Rarely does a top-tier city trade at a discount to the mid-sized capitals.
The Metro Tunnel and the Suburban Rail Loop are rewiring the middle ring, lifting access and amenity across suburbs that are still priced for the old map.
Construction constraints and a persistent building shortfall meet that population inflow head-on. The supply-demand gap that drives rents is widening, not closing.
Soft prices sitting on strengthening fundamentals is what a floor tends to look like. The reward goes to those who are early and selective, not those who wait for the headlines to turn.
Melbourne is not a market to buy blind, and we will not pretend otherwise. The forecasts are genuinely split, with some banks tipping modest gains and others a further easing, and a soft top line means selection matters more here than almost anywhere. This is not a rising tide that lifts everything.
But that is precisely the point. When a global city with the nation’s strongest population growth, tightening rentals and rising rents is also its most out-of-favour capital, the gap between price and fundamentals is the opportunity, for the investor willing to be patient and precise. That is the work our Investor Panel and research team do every month: separating the suburbs where the fundamentals are real from the ones where the discount is deserved.
Angie Zigomanis shares his 3-year outlook, city by city, and Adam Duffy shows how the right property could save you up to $400 a week, with two live opportunities revealed on the night. Free, online, Wednesday 26 August, 6:30pm AEST.
Book a strategy call with a Meridian consultant and we’ll show you where the Melbourne data points next, no cost and no obligation.
Book a consultation →Know someone weighing up the Melbourne market? Refer them to Meridian and receive $1,500 for every successful settlement.
Refer someone →Enter your email to unlock every Due Diligence Report and resource — instantly, no forms. We'll remember you on this device.
Every report is now unlocked across the site.
